Cartoni's Pizza | Italian

Alan M

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

This is my spot. Im here so much I know there names and they already know my order. They are supper nice and friendly. They food is good! Im usually in here at least twice a week. 2 slices extra cheese.

M, Kline (Madje)

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

We're from PA originally, and finding GOOD pizza (non-bitter sauce, firm & stone-baked dough) is difficult in SC. We had slices only but were impressed. Well, Cartoni's is a winner for us! An employee said dough is made fresh daily. They need wait staff so you order at the counter entrance or by phone. Turns out the owner is from the Reading, PA area & used to own Ozzy's Family Fun Center on Route 61 outside of Leesport (my hubby's hometown).

Tracy Count

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

If you love the pizza from Stefano’s, then Cartoni’s won’t let you down. Some true authentic Italian food. Antipasto salad is a little different than Stefano’s, it has bell pepper and iceberg lettuce, but still delicious. The baked bread with marinara was mouth watering. Philly cheese didn’t disappoint. More convenient to Lake City.

Fred W

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

We love experimenting with local restaurants and especially live finding gems like this! Appetizers, specials, entrees, pizza all top notch and at great prices! The service was great too. Not too clingy but timely. We'll be back and recommend you try it too!

Mandy Buchanan

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

My family loves Cartoni's! The staff is so nice and the food is great. My favorite is the Greek Salad with house dressing (oil and vinegar). It's a big salad with lots of feta cheese! So good! Their meatballs are wonderful, too.